Home Sri Lankan Cases Church of the Foursquare Gospel in Sri Lanka and another vs. Kelaniya Pradeshiya Sabha and others

Court
Court of Appeal
Bench
Sri Skandarajah J
Key words
Sec. 8, Urban Development Authority Act
Cases referred to

Viran Corea with Gehan Gunetileka, and S.A. Beling for petitioner.
Anil Silva with Nandana Perera for 1st, 4th respondents.

Counsel who appeared
Date of Decision
7/9/2009
Judgement by Name of Judge/s
Sri Skandarajah J
Noteworthy information relating to the case

Writ issued

Other information

Church of the Foursquare Gospel in Sri Lanka and another vs. Kelaniya Pradeshiya Sabha and others

C.A. 781/2008

Facts of the case

The Petitioner had a Building Plan approved for residential premises under section 8J(1) of the Urban Development Authority Act. The construction was suspended by the approving authority upon the respondents (residents of the area) had complained that the activities and rituals in the premises constituted public nuisance. Petitioner sought a writ of certiorari to quash the decision of cancelling the building plan approval.

Findings related to FoRB

FoRB violation – Conscience (i.e. having or adopting a religion of one’s choice); Discrimination

Holding/Decision

(1) Once approval is granted under Section 8(i) of the UDA Act it is the duty of the petitioners to construct the buildings according to the approval granted. 

 

(2) The respondents have not complained that the petitioners have violated any term or condition in the building permit. 

 

(3) The objection is for the use of musical instruments in high volume and unusually loud religious activities causing breach of peace and sound pollution. There objections are not related to the building that is going to be constructed but it is in relation to an existing state of affairs in relation to an existing building. 

 

(4) The complaints of the use of musical instruments in high volume and unusually loud religious activities causing breach of peace and sound pollution are not related to the building that was approved to be constructed – if the state of affairs is to be controlled these respondents or any other person affected could take action according to law to curtail that situation